How to identify rare Magic: The Gathering cards
By MTG CompareUpdated prices checked
On this page7 sections
Every Magic card tells you its rarity twice: by the colour of the set symbol on the right of the type line, and, on cards printed since 2014, by a letter in the collector line at the bottom left. Rarity is only half the story, though: the same card can exist in several printings, and the printing often decides what it sells for.
Step 1: the colour of the set symbol
Look at the small symbol on the right of the card, level with the type line (the line that says Creature, Instant, Land and so on). Its colour is the rarity:
| Colour | Rarity | Letter |
|---|---|---|
| Black | RarityCommon | LetterC |
| Silver | RarityUncommon | LetterU |
| Gold | RarityRare | LetterR |
| Orange-red | RarityMythic rare | LetterM |
| Purple | RaritySpecial (bonus sheets) | LetterS |
Step 2: the collector line at the bottom left
Cards printed since Magic 2015 (2014) carry a small line of text at the bottom left: the collector number, the rarity letter (C, U, R, M, or L for a basic land), the set code and the language. For example, TRK #7 M is a mythic rare, number 7 of its set.
The collector number matters more than people expect. A number above the set's main run (past the last card of the regular set) usually means a special printing: borderless, showcase or extended-art versions are numbered after the main cards. The number is also the quickest way to find the exact printing in a price search: type the name and the number.
Step 3: which printing it is
Once you know the rarity, check the treatment. These are the differences that change a price most:
- Foil or not. Tilt the card under a light: a foil shines across the whole card. Some sets add special foils (surge, galaxy, textured, raised), each a separate printing with its own price.
- Frame. Borderless (art to the edge), extended art (art wider than the frame) and showcase (a set's own special frame) are separate printings of the same card.
- Serial number. A stamped number like 045/500 on the card means a numbered print run: these are among the most valuable cards of a set.
- Language and condition. The collector line says the language. Condition (corners, edges, scratches) moves the price too; prices here are for ungraded cards.
What each rarity sells for: Star Trek
To show what rarity means in money, here is Star Trek, the newest set we price card by card: the typical (median) TCGplayer market price of each rarity today, and the most valuable card of each. TCGplayer's market price is the recent sale price in US dollars, the higher finish where a card has two.
| Rarity | Cards | Typical | Most valuable |
|---|---|---|---|
| Common | Cards86 | TypicalUS$0.25 | Most valuableMalfunctioning Holodeck (Surge Foil) #571 · US$7.83 |
| Uncommon | Cards163 | TypicalUS$0.34 | Most valuableAnthropological Mission #46 · US$9.71 |
| Rare | Cards208 | TypicalUS$1.68 | Most valuableWill Riker, First in the Field (Showcase) (Surge Foil) #519 · US$64.82 |
| Mythic Rare | Cards73 | TypicalUS$13.01 | Most valuableCaptain Jean-Luc Picard (Showcase) (Surge Foil) #497 · US$209.26 |
Most commons and uncommons sell for cents. A rare or mythic is where the money usually is, but the gap between a typical rare and the best one is large, which is why the next step is to look up the exact printing.
Affiliate link — we may earn a commission. Goes to ebay.com.au.
Same card, different printings
Star Trek's most valuable card today is Captain Jean-Luc Picard. Here is every printing of it we price, cheapest first. Same name, same rarity, very different prices:
| Printing | Number | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Regular | Number#7 | PriceUS$9.12 normal · US$10.18 foil |
| Showcase | Number#363 | PriceUS$16.08 normal · US$29.77 foil |
| Showcase, Surge Foil | Number#497 | PriceUS$209.26 foil |
Questions people ask
- What does the gold symbol on a Magic card mean?
- Gold is rare. Black is common, silver is uncommon, orange-red is mythic rare and purple is a special or bonus-sheet card.
- What does the M at the bottom of a Magic card mean?
- On cards printed since 2014 the collector line at the bottom left gives the rarity as a letter: C common, U uncommon, R rare, M mythic rare, L basic land.
- Are all rare Magic cards valuable?
- No. Many rares sell for under a dollar. The card itself, its printing (foil, borderless, showcase, serialized) and its condition decide the price.
- How do I find what my Magic card is worth?
- Search its name and collector number on our card price pages, which show TCGplayer's market price for each printing and finish.