How much does Recurring Nightmare 72 cost?

The cheapest live price for Recurring Nightmare (72) is currently US$41.50 across 22 stores in the United States, and TCGplayer's market price is US$82.65; every other market we cover is compared on this page too. Prices are read once a day.

How much is Recurring Nightmare in other currencies?

US$41.50 in the United States, A$79.00 in Australia, C$88.95 in Canada and S$116.50 in Singapore. Each is a real listing in the currency its seller bills in.

What set is Recurring Nightmare from?

Recurring Nightmare is card 72 from Exodus (EXO) in Magic: The Gathering. It is a rare Black enchantment.

Where can I buy Recurring Nightmare?

Compare every store selling Recurring Nightmare across the US, Australia, the UK, Singapore, Canada and the EU on this page, then buy from whichever seller offers the lowest total including postage. MTG Compare links straight through to each store.

Recurring Nightmare from Exodus (EXO) #72, Magic: The Gathering card

Card text

Sacrifice a creature, Return this enchantment to its owner's hand: Return target creature card from your graveyard to the battlefield. Activate only as a sorcery.

BlackRareEnchantment

Recurring Nightmare

Name: Recurring Nightmare 72
Brand: Magic: The Gathering
SKU: 4386
Availability: InStock

Enchantment

Exodus (EXO) · 72

Buy on TCGplayer →Buy on eBay →

Cheapest

US$41.50

at Stupid Geeks · postage at checkout

Buy →

Colour identityBlack

Cheapest · the United States

US$41.50

In stock at · US

22 stores

16 stores in other markets

Mana cost

{2}{B}

Cheapest first by item price; postage is added at each store's checkout. How we compare prices →

Price comparison (22) · the United States

oldest listing 11h ago

1
Stupid GeeksCheapest
DMGIn stockpostage at checkout45% under the cheapest NM hereupdated 10h ago
US$41.50View deal →→
2
Tabletop Gaming Center
DMGIn stockpostage at checkout32% under the cheapest NM hereupdated 10h ago
US$51.00View deal →→
3
Zulus Games
HPIn stockpostage at checkout19% under the cheapest NM hereupdated 11h ago
US$60.75View deal →→
4
Gear Gaming Bentonville
MPIn stockpostage at checkout16% under the cheapest NM hereupdated 10h ago
US$62.90View deal →→
5
Games King
MPIn stockpostage at checkout12% under the cheapest NM hereupdated 10h ago
US$66.20View deal →→
6
Gear Gaming Fayetteville
MPIn stockpostage at checkout12% under the cheapest NM hereupdated 10h ago
US$66.20View deal →→
7
Gate City Games
MPIn stockpostage at checkout11% under the cheapest NM hereupdated 10h ago
US$67.00View deal →→
8
TCGplayer
lowest listingIn stockpostage at checkoutupdated 9h agoPaid link
US$69.99Buy on TCGplayer →→
9
Stomping Grounds TCG
MPIn stockpostage at checkout7% under the cheapest NM hereupdated 11h ago
US$70.00View deal →→
10
Tier 1 Games
NMIn stockpostage at checkoutupdated 10h ago
US$75.00View deal →→
11
Dino's Cards & Collectibles
LPIn stockpostage at checkoutcosts more than the cheapest NM hereupdated 10h ago
US$77.30View deal →→
12
Black Dragon Games
LPIn stockpostage at checkoutcosts more than the cheapest NM hereupdated 10h ago
US$79.00View deal →→
13
Gamer's Gauntlet
LPIn stockpostage at checkoutcosts more than the cheapest NM hereupdated 10h ago
US$79.25View deal →→
14
Dynamic Card Collectors
LPIn stockpostage at checkoutcosts more than the cheapest NM hereupdated 10h ago
US$80.00View deal →→
15
Vault Game Store
NMIn stockpostage at checkoutupdated 10h ago
US$80.19View deal →→
16
Astral Comics & Games
NMIn stockpostage at checkoutupdated 10h ago
US$82.70View deal →→
17
Beyond Adventure Games
NMIn stockpostage at checkoutupdated 10h ago
US$82.70View deal →→
18
Games at the Vault (Seibert Technologies)
NMIn stockpostage at checkoutupdated 10h ago
US$82.70View deal →→
19
Card Quest
NMIn stockpostage at checkoutupdated 10h ago
US$83.00View deal →→
20
Impact Gaming Center
NMIn stockpostage at checkoutupdated 10h ago
US$83.50View deal →→
21
Level Up Games MD
NMIn stockpostage at checkoutupdated 10h ago
US$84.99View deal →→
22
Clockwork Games & Events
NMIn stockpostage at checkoutupdated 10h ago
US$89.75View deal →→

2 out-of-stock stores

Stores we have seen stock this card. A sold-out store is checked again at every import.

Cosmic Gameslast seen 22h ago · US$96.00Check →
The Clever Koboldlast seen 6d ago · US$83.00Check →

Prices are collected from public store listings and may change. How we compare prices

Affiliate links: as an eBay Partner Network affiliate and a TCGplayer affiliate, MTG Compare earns from qualifying purchases — at no extra cost to you.

Search eBay for Recurring Nightmare 72

We have no eBay price on file for this card right now — eBay sellers may still list it.

Search eBay →

As an eBay Partner Network affiliate, MTG Compare earns from qualifying purchases.

Watch this price

Keep it on your watchlist to check its price in every store at a glance, free and with no account.

See every card below TCGplayer market →

TCGplayer market pricereference

US$82.65

What this has recently sold for on TCGplayer — a reference value, not a listing.

Affiliate link: as a TCGplayer affiliate, MTG Compare earns from qualifying purchases.

Check on TCGplayer →

AdebayFind Recurring Nightmare 72 on eBayNew, used & graded listings on eBaySearch eBay →

As an eBay Partner Network affiliate, MTG Compare earns from qualifying purchases.

AdTCGplayerShop Magic singles & sealedFast US shippingShop now →

Card text

Sacrifice a creature, Return this enchantment to its owner's hand: Return target creature card from your graveyard to the battlefield. Activate only as a sorcery.

Format legality

StandardNot legal
PioneerNot legal
ModernNot legal
LegacyLegal
VintageLegal
CommanderBanned
PauperNot legal
BrawlNot legal
OathbreakerLegal
HistoricNot legal
TimelessNot legal
AlchemyNot legal

Price history (USD · lowest price)

TCGplayer market shown in USD at an indicative rate

Now US$82.65Low US$82.65High US$82.69

Cheapest US listingTCGplayer market (converted)

About Recurring Nightmare

Recurring Nightmare (72) is a Black Enchantment from Exodus (EXO). It costs {2}{B} and has mana value 3. It is printed at Rare rarity. It is legal in Legacy, Vintage and Oathbreaker.

The cheapest listing we track in the United States is US$41.50, 50% below TCGplayer's US$82.65 market price. 22 stores have it in stock, and the next-cheapest listing is US$51.00, 23% more than the cheapest, so the first row is worth taking.

The United States is the cheapest of the 4 markets that have it, and Singapore is dearest at about 108% more once converted. In each market's own currency the cheapest listings read US$41.50 in the United States, A$79.00 in Australia, C$88.95 in Canada and S$116.50 in Singapore. Conversions use indicative exchange rates, and postage, duty and import tax are not included, so a cheaper market elsewhere is a fact about listings and not a reason to import.

The market price moved +0% over the last 7 days; there is not yet a 30-day window to set that against. It is trading at its 90-day high of US$82.69.

Exodus is a main expansion, released June 1998. Recurring Nightmare has 1 other card in the database, listed further down the page.

Sacrifice a creature, Return this enchantment to its owner's hand: Return target creature card from your graveyard to the battlefield. Activate only as a sorcery.

More Enchantment cards →More Rare cards →More Black cards →

Frequently asked questions

How much does Recurring Nightmare 72 cost?: The cheapest live price for Recurring Nightmare (72) is currently US$41.50 across 22 stores in the United States, and TCGplayer's market price is US$82.65; every other market we cover is compared on this page too. Prices are read once a day.
How much is Recurring Nightmare in other currencies?: US$41.50 in the United States, A$79.00 in Australia, C$88.95 in Canada and S$116.50 in Singapore. Each is a real listing in the currency its seller bills in.
What set is Recurring Nightmare from?: Recurring Nightmare is card 72 from Exodus (EXO) in Magic: The Gathering. It is a rare Black enchantment.
Where can I buy Recurring Nightmare?: Compare every store selling Recurring Nightmare across the US, Australia, the UK, Singapore, Canada and the EU on this page, then buy from whichever seller offers the lowest total including postage. MTG Compare links straight through to each store.

Recurring Nightmare price by market

Recurring Nightmare is cheapest in the United States at US$41.50 and dearest in Singapore at S$116.50 (≈ US$86.30), a 108% spread across the 4 markets stocking it. Each seller bills in its own currency; converted figures are indicative only.

Market	Cheapest	≈ USD	Stores
United StatesCheapestYour market	US$41.50postage at checkout	—	22
Australia	A$79.00postage at checkout ≈ US$52.67	US$52.67	5
Canada	C$88.95postage at checkout ≈ US$64.93	US$64.93	9
Singapore	S$116.50postage at checkout ≈ US$86.30	US$86.30	2

Prices are live listings in each market, in the currency that seller charges. The “≈ USD” column is an indicative conversion for comparison only: not a quote, and not what you'll be billed. Stores generally ship within their own market, and international postage, duty and import tax aren't included, so a cheaper market elsewhere isn't necessarily cheaper to get delivered to you.

This week's biggest price movesRisers, drops and best-value buys, updated dailySee the movers →MTG Compare

Do more with this price

Card details

Card number: 72
Set: Exodus (EXO)
Set type: Expansion
Released: 15 June 1998
Rarity: Rare (R)
Printing: Standard
Type line: Enchantment
Colour: Black
Colour identity: Black
Mana cost: {2}{B}
Finish: Non-foil

TCGplayer listing: Recurring Nightmare

Also available on eBay

Live listings, including used and international sellers: a useful cross-check on the store prices above, and often the only source for older printings. Graded slabs get their own tab, so they never distort the raw price. eBay prices are sellers' asking prices and are never ranked with the stores.

ebayBuy Recurring Nightmare 72 on eBaySearch new, used & graded listings on eBay.Shop on eBay →

As an eBay Partner Network affiliate, MTG Compare earns from qualifying purchases.

Affiliate link: as an eBay Partner Network affiliate, MTG Compare earns from qualifying purchases — at no extra cost to you.