Commander: Innistrad: Midnight Hunt card list & prices

Commander: Innistrad: Midnight Hunt (MIC) was released on 24 September 2021. It has 189 printings on TCGplayer: every rarity and every Borderless, Extended Art, Showcase or foil-pattern version counted separately, because each is priced separately, and each has a Normal and a Foil price of its own.

Each card below shows the cheapest in-stock listing we track in the United States, in USD; “≈” marks TCGplayer's market price where no US store has the card. Open a card for every store's price.

MTG Compare lists 189 cards in Commander: Innistrad: Midnight Hunt (MIC), 13 of which have a live price in the United States right now. The rest are tracked but not currently stocked by any store we monitor; they reappear here priced the moment one lists them.

Prices run from US$0.25 to US$11.30, with a median of US$3.94. Value is spread unusually evenly — no single card dominates the cost, so completing this group is a steady accumulation rather than one expensive purchase.

The cards to know: Wilhelt, the Rotcleaver at US$11.30, Avacyn's Memorial at US$7.86, Hordewing Skaab at US$5.00. At the other end, Verdurous Gearhulk is the cheapest way in at US$0.25.

Buying a set card by card and buying sealed are different questions — the Box EV calculator answers the second, and the prices below answer the first. The calculator values each card at TCGplayer's US market price, converted, rather than the cheapest listing shown here, so its per-card figures will differ.